Level 1 · 9 / 10

The Burning Masterpiece

Which do you save?

The Burning Masterpiece

A fire breaks out in a famous art gallery. The original Mona Lisa is going to burn to ash. You are standing next to a perfect 3D-printed replica. It is atom-for-atom identical to the original. You can save the replica or save a blurry photograph of the original taken by a famous artist. You only have time to grab one.

Which do you save?

Then ask

  • If the replica is physically identical, why do we care about the original?
  • Does the history of an object live inside the object?

The classics and some new ones. A scenario, the question it forces, and the follow-ups that make it bite.

More at this level

  1. The Same Boat
  2. Two Boxes
  3. The Shadows
  4. The Room of Slips
  5. Mary's Grey Room
  6. The Heap
  7. The Extra Change
  8. The Group Mark