Level 2 · 45 / 53

The Broken Window

Do you say your son did it?

The Broken Window

Your son kicks a football through the neighbour’s window. No one sees it happen. Minutes later, another child is blamed because their ball is found in the garden. Replacing the glass will cost you £400.

Do you say your son did it?

Then ask

  • Would you speak up if the other child faced no punishment?
  • Should your son pay from his savings?
  • What lesson do you teach by protecting him?

The classics and some new ones. A scenario, the question it forces, and the follow-ups that make it bite.

More at this level

  1. The Pond
  2. The Deathbed Promise
  3. The Windfall
  4. The Payslip
  5. The Ring
  6. The Novel
  7. Who Stays
  8. The Will